Satan is a clever fellow. You think you are using your god given reason and common sense, but really, you have been deceived by the ultimate enemy. It is his words you speak now, the god of this world!
The Passion is everything you could expect and more (at least from the little I saw). The bad guys (the Jews, and to a lesser extent, the Romans) are dipicted in the most cartoonish manner imaginable. Have you seen Commando, with big Arnie? Or the Russians in Rambo 2 and 3? We are talking that kind of careful characterisation, and sophisticated explication of their motives. Oh, and the Devil is transgendered, it seems. It contains all the usual Christian ahistorical horseshit about the ancient world. There were a couple of sops to modern scholarship, like having Jesus both tied and nailed onto his cross (so as not to abandon the wounds of the stigmata and Turin shroud, but also being able to say "well, thats why he didnt fall off, since we accept that nails in your hands cant hold the bodies weight alone") However, since the bible only mentions the nails, that seems to me to be somewhat of an... editorial decision? Something I was assured by the faithful in Ohio was completely impossible in such a "straight from the book" adaptation. Quick review, based on much careful thought, reading, and having seen 30 minutes of the film: Complete Bollocks.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
timeasmymeasure
no subject
Date: 2006-04-15 04:03 am (UTC)The Passion is everything you could expect and more (at least from the little I saw). The bad guys (the Jews, and to a lesser extent, the Romans) are dipicted in the most cartoonish manner imaginable. Have you seen Commando, with big Arnie? Or the Russians in Rambo 2 and 3? We are talking that kind of careful characterisation, and sophisticated explication of their motives. Oh, and the Devil is transgendered, it seems. It contains all the usual Christian ahistorical horseshit about the ancient world. There were a couple of sops to modern scholarship, like having Jesus both tied and nailed onto his cross (so as not to abandon the wounds of the stigmata and Turin shroud, but also being able to say "well, thats why he didnt fall off, since we accept that nails in your hands cant hold the bodies weight alone") However, since the bible only mentions the nails, that seems to me to be somewhat of an... editorial decision? Something I was assured by the faithful in Ohio was completely impossible in such a "straight from the book" adaptation.
Quick review, based on much careful thought, reading, and having seen 30 minutes of the film: Complete Bollocks.